On Wed. June 24, we held a Climate Café, where about 2 dozen people met to learn about The Greatest Lie Ever Told.

The Documentary: For those who want to watch the whole documentary, Frontline’s “The Power of Big Oil,” here are links to the three parts (it’s definitely worth a watch – very well made!):

The Podcast: During the discussion, we mentioned the “Drilled” podcast. Season 1, “The Origins of Climate Denial” (eight episodes) covers much of the ground we explored, including Big Oil’s use of the same playbook used by Big Tobacco, the key public relations firms (including Ivy Lee) and their link to Nazi propaganda methods, and how Big Oil’s 100-year-plus misinformation campaign is arguably the biggest in world history.

The Storylines: We talked about the importance of stories to this work. Here are three examples to think about:

  • Story #1: Sounding the Alarm, Calling for Solutions

    “Burning fossil fuels creates many negative effects: an overheating planet; air pollution, disease, and death; bloody wars and supply line blockades, and more. We need to transition to cleaner energy sources as swiftly and effectively as possible!”

    This storyline is essentially an alarm bell, appealing directly to our fears and our care for the world.

    • Story #2: Calling Out the True Villain, Calling Us to Fight Back

    “Big Oil knew. They lied. They spread misinformation (arguably the biggest misinformation campaign in world history) to confuse us, divide us, and profit at our expense. They profited. And now they’re trying to get away with it. Are we going to let them?”

    This storyline is essentially an exposé and accusation, appealing directly to our outrage and sense of justice, rallying us to stand up and fight back.

    • Story #3: Announcing Opportunities, Calling Us to Build a Better Future

    “The transition to clean energy is already underway – and the future is exciting! Cleaner air, cheaper energy, more prosperity, better products, fewer wars. Let’s help advance the transition – and benefit from it!”

    This storyline is essentially an upbeat call to action, appealing directly to our desire for a better, healthier, more peaceful future (and our desire not to miss out!).

    What we were exploring at the Cafe was Story #2. What are its particular advantages? 

    First, having an adversary (a “True Villain”) can harness our righteous anger and rally us to act. With the midterms approaching and the national mood skeptical of both Big Corporate and Big Corruption, that anger and action can be helpful if we harness it. Anger is often more “activating” than fear, alarm, or hopeful excitement.

    Second, Story #2 also helps guard against the false idea that *we* are the true villains here, that our “carbon footprints” are the fundamental root of the problem. Remember, the “carbon footprint” concept (and calculator) was invented by none other than the PR arm of British Petroleum, precisely to shift the spotlight away from the big corporate and governmental actors who actually affect our energy system at scale.

    And third, Story #2 points toward some specific next steps. In a word, Story #2 exposes fraud, and one powerful way to address fraud is through the courts. Here in NH, we did exactly that in 1998 with a successful lawsuit against Big Tobacco. We did it again in 2003 with a successful lawsuit against Exxon (for groundwater contamination). And today, five of the six New England states are currently suing Big Oil for climate fraud, and New Hampshire is the only one that isn’t.

    What Can We Do?

    One clear action step, then, is to put pressure on NH Attorney General Formella, and on Governor Ayotte. Another is to get involved with the Conservation Law Foundation. Another is to spread the word about Story #2, and bring our friends and neighbors on board with the vision for New Hampshire taking Big Oil to court.

    They knew, they lied. They spewed an expensive sludge of misinformation, arguably the biggest propaganda campaign in world history. They profited. They stole from us, forcing us to pay many of their costs and setting the clean energy transition back 40 years or more. And they’re trying to get away with it.